Go to top

Shopify Order Fulfillment: A Detailed Guide for 2024

Gain valuable insights into Shopify order fulfillment through our blog, where we delve into the different types, models, built-in capabilities, and key elements of this essential process.

Team Hopstack
April 18, 2024

In this blog

In today's e-commerce landscape, Shopify stands as a titan among platforms for Direct-to-Consumer (DTC) businesses. It's not just a storefront; it's an expansive ecosystem powering millions of businesses in more than 175 countries, boasting a remarkable 28% share of the U.S. e-commerce market. The Shopify platform offers robust order fulfillment capabilities, including streamlined storefront design, extensive app integrations, and comprehensive analytics—all tailored to empower Shopify sellers to reach a global audience with ease.

For millions of sellers on the platform, Shopify order fulfillment is the difference between a thriving online business and a struggling one. It requires efficient inventory management, selecting the right products, packaging them securely, and shipping them promptly. Each of these steps must be executed efficiently to meet and exceed customer expectations. Shopify offers integrated tools and services to help Shopify sellers deliver a seamless fulfillment process that aligns with their business model and scales with their growth.

Types of Shopify Order Fulfillment Services

Shopify provides three types of order fulfillment for sellers with varying supply chain maturity. Understanding the different types of Shopify fulfillment is essential to managing e-commerce operations and making the most of supply chain operations.

Automatic Fulfillment

This is the "set it and forget it" approach to order fulfillment. When a customer places an order, it's automatically marked as fulfilled in the Shopify system, and the process of getting the item to the customer begins immediately without any additional input from the seller. 

This method is ideal for digital products or when you have a reliable dropshipping arrangement or third-party logistics provider (3PL) that handles your fulfillment process. Think of it like having a virtual assistant who takes care of shipping as soon as an order is placed, similar to Amazon’s FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) service, where the entire fulfillment process is out of the seller's hands.

Manual Fulfillment

In this method, the seller has full control and must manually confirm each order before it is shipped. This is often used for custom-made products, items that need a verification process before sending, pre-orders, or when a seller prefers to greater autonomy over order and inventory management.

 It’s like a barista waiting for your order before starting to make your coffee; nothing happens until you give the go-ahead. It's comparable to platforms like Etsy, where many products are made-to-order and require a hands-on approach.

Partial Fulfillment

Sometimes, an order contains multiple items, and not all of them are ready to be shipped at the same time. Partial fulfillment allows Shopify sellers to send out available items immediately while waiting to fulfill the rest of the order until a later date. Imagine a restaurant that serves your appetizer while the chef prepares the main course—it's about delivering what's ready to keep the customer satisfied while the rest is being prepared.

Different Models in Shopify Order Fulfillment

Shopify offers various order fulfillment models for store owners. Each model has its strengths and trade-offs, and the right choice often depends on the size of the business, the types of products sold, sales volume, and the level of control a seller wishes to maintain over the customer experience. It’s important to understand the differences to identify the right approach for your business goals and growth trajectory.

1. Self or In-house Fulfillment

Shopify sellers who opt for self-fulfillment manage their inventory and the entire fulfillment process in-house. This approach usually requires a heavy investment in physical space, equipment, and labor as businesses scale and expand their online reach.

Self-fulfillment offers complete autonomy at every stage of the order fulfillment process, making it ideal for businesses that require customization as part of their brand experience.

In-house fulfillment allows sellers to have direct control over their inventory, packing, storage, shipping, and reverse logistics, which can translate to a personalized customer experience. However, this can be capital-intensive and may not be as scalable without significant investment in warehouse management software, warehouse automation, and logistics.

2. Third-Party Logistics (3PL)

Outsourcing fulfillment to a third-party logistics or 3PL provider is a common strategy for Shopify sellers. 3PL companies leverage their existing supply chain and logistics network, and tech stack to handle storage, packing, shipping, and returns on behalf of the store owners. 3PL providers offer access to more shipping options and better carrier rates, leading to improved profitability overall.

Pros of using a 3PL include:

  • Reduced overhead costs as there’s no need for warehouse space.
  • Scalability, as most 3PLs can handle increased volume without issue.
  • Expertise in logistics that small sellers may lack.

Potential cons of 3PL fulfillment:

  • Less control over the fulfillment process.
  • Potential for added costs if sales volume doesn’t meet certain thresholds.
  • Dependence on the 3PL’s reliability and performance.

3. Dropshipping

In this Shopify fulfillment model, the seller never takes possession or title of the inventory. Instead, when an order is placed on their Shopify store, it’s forwarded directly to the supplier or manufacturer, who then ships the product directly to the customer. 

Dropshipping can be an attractive option because it minimizes the risk and cost associated with holding inventory. Every step of the fulfillment process is handled by the manufacturer, thereby reducing supply chain complexity and eliminating any middleman in delivering the product to the end consumer. 

However, the downsides include less control over shipping times and product quality, as well as typically lower profit margins. The lack of control over the fulfillment process can lead to problems further down the line if the supplier or manufacturer is unreliable.

4. Amazon Multichannel Fulfillment (MCF) and Buy with Prime

With MCF, Shopify sellers store their inventory in Amazon's fulfillment centers, and Amazon handles fulfillment for orders placed on Shopify or other non-Amazon channels. This can offer sellers the advantage of leveraging Amazon's vast logistics network and swift delivery times.

The "Buy with Prime" feature on Shopify allows Prime customers to experience the same fast shipping they are accustomed to on Amazon. This can significantly boost conversion rates for sellers. However, relying on Amazon’s infrastructure means adhering to its rules and fee structures, which might not always favor the seller.

Shopify and Amazon's Buy with Prime

5. Shopify Fulfillment Network (SFN)

SFN functions similarly to a Fourth-Party Logistics provider (4PL), where Shopify itself manages the fulfillment process through a network of partnered fulfillment centers. Since Shopify manages the relationship with the fulfillment centers, this can be a more hands-off approach for Shopify sellers.

This service is designed to integrate seamlessly with a seller’s Shopify store, potentially offering benefits such as lower shipping rates and simplified operations. Store owners should evaluate how this integration can streamline their operations compared to other third-party solutions. SFN is designed to scale with your business. As your order volume grows, SFN's infrastructure and fulfillment network can accommodate the increased demand. 

6. Hybrid Model

Many Shopify sellers find that a hybrid fulfillment model — leveraging a combination of self-fulfillment, 3PLs, drop shipping, and networks like SFN — can offer the best balance. 

A hybrid fulfillment model allows for:

  • Better inventory distribution across different regions
  • Cost efficiencies by utilizing the most advantageous fulfillment option based on specific scenarios
  • Channel diversification to avoid over-reliance on a single fulfillment method
  • Expanded serviceable area, potentially offering faster delivery to a wider range of customers

Shopify’s Built-in Capabilities for Order Fulfillment

Shopify offers comprehensive built-in order fulfillment capabilities that can be further expanded with its App Library. This ecosystem not only makes it possible for sellers to manage the Shopify fulfillment process efficiently but also offers the flexibility necessary to tailor the experience to the unique needs of their business and customers.

Order Management

Shopify's order management system allows sellers to view, track, and manage orders from a centralized dashboard. Sellers can manually fulfill orders, capture payments, restock returned items, and handle customer interactions. Automated order fulfillment workflows can be set up to decrease the time spent on repetitive tasks, such as sending confirmation emails or updating order statuses.

Figure: Inventory management activities sellers can perform with an in-house or third-party application. (Source: Shopify)

These applications streamline the flow of information between disparate systems, helping Shopify store owners manage product availability across sales channels, determine when to prepare purchase orders and consolidate inventory and order data into a single, centralized source.

Products and Inventory Management

The platform enables Shopify store managers to add products, set stock levels, and update inventory across all sales channels in real-time. Shopify's inventory management system can track stock counts, and automatically stop selling products when inventory runs out, reducing the risk of overselling. It also facilitates inventory forecasting, helping sellers understand when to restock.

Shopify's Inventory and Product Management

Shopify Shipping

Shopify Shipping simplifies the shipping process by offering discounted rates with major carriers, which can be directly integrated into the checkout process. Sellers can print shipping labels, manage order fulfillment, and track shipments all from within the Shopify admin page, making it easier to get products to customers efficiently.

Shopify's App Library

Shopify's App Library contains a vast array of applications that can extend the platform's native capabilities. This flexibility allows sellers to avail of custom order fulfillment services on Shopify to meet specific business needs.

Shopify App Store

Range of third-party services available on the app store

The Shopify App Store offers new applications and third-party services that sellers can use within their own Shopify stores. Depending on their business model and growth strategy, store owners can choose to integrate apps for store design, marketing and conversion, orders and shipping, store management, and more. According to a study, there are approximately 6,755 active and 623 inactive apps on the Shopify App Store.

Some of the more popular types of applications on the Shopify App Store are:

  • Fulfillment Software: There are apps designed to connect sellers with Shopify fulfillment services, providing options such as on-demand, same-day delivery, or integration with third-party logistics providers.
  • Shipping Software: These apps can further streamline shipping logistics, offering features such as bulk label printing, advanced shipping rules based on product type or destination, and more in-depth tracking capabilities.
  • Returns Management: Efficient returns management is crucial for customer satisfaction. Apps in this category can automate much of the process, offering prepaid labels, streamlined communications, and analytics to help sellers understand the reasons behind returns.
  • POS and Checkout Tools: For sellers who operate both online and offline, point-of-sale (POS) apps ensure that the fulfillment process is smooth regardless of where the sale takes place. These tools can synchronize online and in-store sales, manage inventory, and help sellers provide a cohesive brand experience.

Key Elements of Shopify Order Fulfillment

Whether it’s the speed of delivery, cost management, risk mitigation through diversification, superior customer experience, or efficient returns management, Shopify’s fulfillment services offer a compelling package for sellers looking to optimize their operations and grow their business.

1. Speed

Speed in delivery is a significant competitive advantage. Shopify's order fulfillment solutions cater to the modern customer's expectations with fast cart conversion and quick deliveries. Shopify leverages its network to reduce transit times with options like one-day or two-day shipping. 

Fast delivery is not just a luxury; it’s often a deciding factor in e-commerce. According to a 2023 consumer survey, nearly 24% of online shoppers will abandon a cart if they perceive the shipping to be slow. Shopify's integration with various carriers ensures that the quickest delivery option is available, and the Shopify Fulfillment Network (SFN) places inventory close to customers, further reducing delivery times.

2. Cost Efficiency

Reducing the average cost per order is crucial to maintain profitability. Outsourcing order fulfillment eliminates the need to invest heavily in logistics and shipping processes, further reducing the overhead costs leading to order fulfillment efficiency

In addition, Shopify order fulfillment services leverage an extensive carrier network to negotiate better shipping rates with major carriers, which are often much lower than what a small business could secure independently. By analyzing order history and trends via Shopify's platform analytics, store owners can optimize their packaging solutions and inventory levels, avoiding unnecessary storage or shipping costs. 

Real-time insights and demand forecasting capabilities allow Shopify store owners to optimize inventory flow, reducing instances of overstocking. For example, if data shows that certain products are frequently bought together, sellers can pre-package these as a bundle, saving on both materials and shipping costs.

3. Diversification

Diversification in fulfillment can mitigate risk and improve performance. Shopify enables inventory distribution across multiple locations, allowing for strategic placement of goods closer to customers to cut down on shipping times and order fulfillment costs

Employing multiple carriers ensures that sellers aren't overly reliant on a single service, which can be a safeguard against disruptions. For instance, if one carrier faces a strike or logistical issues, another can take over without affecting delivery times. 

A hybrid fulfillment setup, utilizing a mix of in-house, 3PL, and dropshipping, allows sellers to adapt and optimize per order, sales volume, and product type.

4. Customer Experience

Shopify’s fulfillment ecosystem focuses on enhancing customer experience by enabling fast deliveries, providing real-time updates, and offering customization options at checkout. An informative order tracking page, integrated within Shopify’s system, offers self-service capabilities and reduces the need for them to contact customer service. For example, a customer purchasing a gift can choose a specific delivery date, include a personal note, and track the delivery process step-by-step, all of which add to a positive shopping experience.

5. Returns Management

In the DTC space, an effective returns management process is essential. Shopify estimates the average e-commerce returns rate in the United States is between 20% to 30%. It not only impacts customer satisfaction but also the bottom line. Shopify provides streamlined returns management, allowing customers to easily initiate returns, which can be a decisive factor in their choice to shop. 

A well-handled return translates to a quicker restocking cycle and potentially more sales. For instance, a dress that is returned because of size issues can be quickly processed and made available for another customer rather than sitting idle in inventory. Additionally, built-in analytics help sellers understand the reasons behind returns and identify fraudulent behavior, allowing them to take corrective actions.

By integrating these key elements into their operations, Shopify sellers can potentially outperform competitors and provide a level of service that meets or exceeds customer expectations. 

Hopstack for High-volume Shopify Order Fulfillment

Elevate your Shopify fulfillment process with Hopstack. Our high-volume order fulfillment capabilities are designed to handle every step of the process, from pick and pack to shipping. 

Our system streamlines your operations with real-time order, product, and inventory synchronization with Shopify, ensuring accuracy and complete visibility. 

Simplify carrier selection with our real-time rate shopping feature and maintain oversight with integrated carrier performance tracking. Our reverse logistics capabilities can manage returns effortlessly and offer insights to drive your business forward through our analytics and customizable dashboards. 

Take the first step towards fulfillment excellence — contact us for a demo and see what Hopstack can do for you.

Maximize the performance of your DTC fulfillment

Hopstack for DTC Fulfillment
Hopstack white logo